Mars One: Headed for Disaster?

Now that we've seen the plan for the Mars One mission and met some of the finalists, we need to evaluate whether or not this project is ever going to get off the ground. Mars One has many critics and skeptics in the scientific community.

Here are a couple of articles that outline the concerns, hazards, and realities of their attempt to colonize Mars.

Is a One-Way Trip to Mars Doomed to Fail?

Mars One: Exciting Adventure or Hoax?


These two articles focus more on the costs involved and the reality of funding (or lack thereof).

Neil DeGrasse Tyson Thinks Mars One Mission Will Fail to Get Financial Backing

Mars One Project is Doomed to Failure and Could Endanger the Future of Science

Discussion Questions:

In your opinion, what is the biggest obstacle, funding or lack of scientific technology for sustained living on Mars?

Is it ethical to send humans to Mars (with no way to bring them back) with all of the dangers involved?

Do you think this is a more of a publicity stunt/financial scam than it is a genuine mission to Mars?

If Mars One does not raise the money necessary, what should they do with all of the contributions?